The New Prose
by Zen
Posted on Sunday, August 23, 2009Building on my previous post about game designers as the new existentialists, I found these words by Rorty rather stirring:
... deconstruction ... needs a clear distinction between philosophy and literature. For the kind of reading which has come to be called "deconstructionist" requires two different straight persons: a macho professional philosopher who is insulted by the suggestion that he has submitted to a textual exigency, and a naive producer of literature whose jaw drops when she learns that her work has been suppported by philosophical oppositions. The philosopher had thought of himself as speaking a sparse, pure, transparent language. The poetess shyly hoped that her unmediated woodnotes might please. Both reel back in horror when the deconstructionist reveals that each has been making use of complex idioms to which the other has contributed. Both go all to pieces at this news. A wild disorder overtakes their words. Their whimpers blend into interminable androgynous keening. Once again, deconstructionist intervention has produced a splendidly diffuse irresolution.
There is something suspiciously old-fashioned about this way of setting up one's subjects. It is a long time since we have had writers who considered themselves in the business of providing pleasure. ... [Essays on Heidegger and Others, p.86]
Many will tell you of the harm Derrida (inadvertently I think) caused to literary analysis, and that phenomenon is the specific target of that passage. Rorty was concerned with the assumptions Derrida's criticisms of philosophical thinking made about both fields, but this came on the heels of his own significant bias toward prose:
As a way of counteracting Heidegger and, more generally, the kind of post-Heideggerian thinking which refuses to see the West as a continuing adventure, I want to put forward Charles Dickens as a sort of anti-Heidegger. If [archaeologists of the future] were, for some reason, unable to preserve the works of both men, I should much prefer that they preserve Dickens's. For Dickens could help them grasp a complex of attitudes which was important to the West, and perhaps unique to the West, in a way that neither Heidegger nor any other philosopher could. The example of Dickens could help them think of the novel, and particularly the novel of moral protest, as the genre in which the West excelled. From this point of view, the interaction of West and East is better exemplified by the playing of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony by the students in Tienanmen Square than by the steel mills of Korea or the influence of Japanese prints on European painters of the nineteenth century. [Essays on Heidegger and Others, pp.67-68]
Heidegger famously elevated "the poetical" in his later years, and Rorty seems hellbent on elevating the morality play instead. Heidegger's distaste for Western metaphysics and its insistence on objective fact appears, to Rorty, to be a distaste for the considerable social and political strides that have been made in the West. This essay was published in 1991, and I would love for Rorty to have been able to draw on the considerable cross-pollenation of Eastern and Western game development instead of century-old paintings inspired by still older Japanese prints. That said, it makes little difference to his point: instead of trying to express some transcendent quality through poetry, one should instead concern oneself with tackling moral and social problems by connecting them with people, with characters.

You can disagree, and claim that Kojima has always been playing the philosopher/poetess game. People seem to think that he's always been courting some kind of recognition from the world of acknowledged intellectuals, or that he really still wants to be a film director. I say that he's failed spectacularly at both, to his benefit. I'm not one for Dickens, but what Rorty claims Dickens can accomplish is something that video games can accomplish tenfold. I don't think anybody can play a Kojima game without being bothered by him. Some people criticize the game, thinking they're bothered by it, but it's always Kojima. It's always Kojima making you look at what you're doing, what you're not doing, what you're ever doing. And he always considers himself to be in the business of providing pleasure.
<2D>
Daikai10
Decide Weapons
[Supple Think]
...and luck
© Supple Think. Powered by Blogger.
Topics
- History (17)
- Ethics (12)
- games as art (12)
- you made me do this (12)
- Philosophy (11)
- arcade games (11)
- opinion (11)
- fighting games (10)
- YupYupYup (9)
- developers (9)
- I see what you did there (8)
- Japan (8)
- fresh air (8)
- hope (8)
- neckbeard (8)
- street fighter (8)
- :awesome: (7)
- Death (7)
- Violence (7)
- Wii (7)
- New Games Journalism (6)
- Nintendo is screwing us again (6)
- Punishment (6)
- Speed Runs (6)
- What is a man? (6)
- Earthbound (5)
- Nonlinear (5)
- Sandbox (5)
- Xbox 360 (5)
- gamecenter cx (5)
- oh god another list (5)
- puzzle games (5)
- Arino Kachou (4)
- Chrono Trigger (4)
- Confessions (4)
- Developer Photos (4)
- GOD HAND (4)
- Metal Gear (4)
- Metroid (4)
- PS3 (4)
- PStriple (4)
- Time Sink (4)
- What's happening to my body? (4)
- adventure games (4)
- hardware (4)
- intelligent lasers (4)
- post something dammit (4)
- 1UP Photos (3)
- Angst (3)
- Castlevania (3)
- Heidegger (3)
- Mario (3)
- Mega Man (3)
- Persona (3)
- SDA (3)
- Skills (3)
- Sup (3)
- Virtual Console (3)
- communism (3)
- durfy (3)
- money (3)
- owen wilson (3)
- rap (3)
- videos (3)
- watch this it's awesome (3)
- zippers (3)
- 2D (2)
- Animu (2)
- Clover Studios (2)
- Devil May Cry (2)
- Dongs (2)
- Game Addiction (2)
- Grand Theft Auto (2)
- Guitar Hero (2)
- Jack Thompson (2)
- Luigi (2)
- Planetary (2)
- Platinum Games (2)
- SHMUP (2)
- Suda 51 (2)
- Suikoden (2)
- Super Metroid (2)
- Xenogears (2)
- Zelda (2)
- animation (2)
- arcade stick (2)
- beat-'em-ups (2)
- bling (2)
- brown (2)
- copyright infringement (2)
- david caruso (2)
- import (2)
- marx (2)
- music games (2)
- panda (2)
- poe (2)
- starcraft (2)
- vaporware (2)
- Aletheia (1)
- American McGee (1)
- BFG (1)
- Bayonetta (1)
- Braid (1)
- Contra (1)
- Dark Souls (1)
- Derrida (1)
- Eiji Aonuma (1)
- Final Fantasy (1)
- Game Maker (1)
- George Kamitani (1)
- Gitaroo Man (1)
- Grasshopper Manufacture (1)
- Halo 3 (1)
- Heedful Circumspection (1)
- Hello Kitty (1)
- Hideo Kojima (1)
- Intergalactic (1)
- Jean Baudrillard (1)
- Jenova Chen (1)
- Jonathan Blow (1)
- Kierkegaard (1)
- Levinas (1)
- Locke (1)
- Lurks (1)
- MMORPG (1)
- Masato Maegawa (1)
- Mr. Driller (1)
- Nazis (1)
- Orange Box (1)
- Pikmin (1)
- RTS (1)
- Rock Band (1)
- Rorty (1)
- Shigeru Miyamoto (1)
- Sonic the Hedgehog (1)
- Star Ocean (1)
- Super Mario Galaxy (1)
- Super Mario Sunshine (1)
- Taito (1)
- Tanks (1)
- Temporality (1)
- Treasure (1)
- Vanillaware (1)
- WiiWare (1)
- XNA (1)
- Yoshi (1)
- bbs (1)
- candy (1)
- cave story (1)
- citadel (1)
- dialup (1)
- failure (1)
- garry (1)
- geometry wars (1)
- harvest (1)
- kotaku sucks (1)
- peripherals (1)
- progaming (1)
- robotfindskitten (1)
- sociopathy (1)
- solipsism (1)
- spin and win (1)
- t'khasi orion (1)
- tower defense (1)